Saturday, February 11, 2012

SOPA

In this week’s lecture, we have been discussing a new bill that the United States has been trying to pass for the last couple of weeks called Stop Online Piracy Act, which in short means SOPA. What this bill does is expand the right of the law enforcement of the U.S to try to stop copyright use from anyone on the internet. Not only is this a huge bill but it can cause so many conflicts down the road between people and their business. In the other hand, the bill can also help many other powerful figures in the world. There are a couple of reasons why this bill has been created or thought off in the first place. One reason is that people that have big business on the internet are tired of others taking their information and putting it on their sites. Well you know that when you’re online, you see a bunch of videos, information, or pictures on people sites, and it makes you wonder, how they feel about this. A couple of classes ago we went over 2 videos that talked about SOPA and the positives and negatives about them. 


The first video was about thirty seconds long and was pro SOPA, which means they support the bill and actions on it and the second one was two minutes long and talked what SOPA means and the positive and negatives about it. As a class we needed to view both videos and describe what’s going on in each one of them. Also to see what’s the difference in visuals, music, color, and voice on both video presentations. When you see video one, the first thing that pops in your head is, is this a campaign ad of some sort. The dark suspense music and voice seems typical to the average person watching this. I really had no idea what SOPA was until we were discussing it in class and now seeing this video, I got a good idea on what the negative effects it might have on people who have certain jobs. First of all, the video is right about how people online are taking jobs from others from illegally downloading music and transporting counterfeit goods to others around the world. 


One of the biggest things is the music downloading and the stolen videos because all the money that has been put in those categories is getting taken away from criminals online. But in other terms, the second video has a great feel to it. It has a cartoon look to it which is intriguing to an audience. This video basically explains what SOPA is and how this bill may change the future as we know it. Being Human in the Age of the Electronic Mob by Lee Siegel is a great article with fantastic facts. This quote I think really signifies what the article is about “the internet has much in common with the automobile. Both have evolved in an arbitrary ways, which people nonetheless view as inevitable and inexorable”. We know that the internet can be bad sometimes but we do not care at all.

6 comments:

  1. SOPA is obviously a controversial topic. I go back and forth in my head agreeing with it and then disagreeing with it. I am all for protecting people’s work and not stealing it for any purpose. There are so many web designers in the world that work so hard and end up having their work stolen. This goes for a number of other professions, such as singers, writers, entertainers, etc. There is not much they can do to stop the theft. There are billions of people on the internet. How will they track down the one person who is stealing their work? That is why I disagree with SOPA it seems impossible to me to stop all the theft that is occurring. People download illegal music every day. The government cannot send 12 year olds to jail who are illegally downloading Justin Bieber music. Their parents cannot get sent to jail either for “allowing it” when they might have not known. Then the issue of parenting comes up but that is a whole other topic. I think that it is impossible to stop people from illegally downloading things when they might not know that what they are doing is illegal in the first place.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The SOPA bill is a good idea, and I think it comes from good intentions, but they definitely have to think it through a bit more. I agree that they should definitely try to help protect people's copyright rights but taking sites away such as Youtube and tumblr will not make a bill such as this successful. I do like how you commented on how the videos presented themselves to the public because that definitely has an impact on whomever may be watching. I definitely started to believe that the SOPA act would tear apart any website that had any relation to some else's song while watching the video that was against it, but I also got the feeling that these artists and writers needed help to keep their work to themselves and be represented correctly. When it comes to illegal downloading, I am one hundred percent sure that it will never be able to be controlled unless the internet is controlled to an extent that no one can ever imagine. The internet is huge, there is absolutely no way that the government can regulate the whole thing. If one illegal downloading site shuts down, two more will open up because its not difficult to do so. Also, there are so many skilled hackers out there that it makes illegal downloading so easy. I am worried that eventually the artists will not get correct recognition for anything, but then again who is going to stop all of this without ruining the way the internet works completely?

    ReplyDelete
  3. What I get from all the discussion we had on the Stop Online Piracy Act is that none of us truly are knowledgable enough on how the bill will truly effect the Internet, companies, and us as users of the Internet. Short videos can do their best to explain it but none of us have any idea to what degree the Internet can actually be monitored. That is why I think the companies that do not want SOPA to pass such as Google, Wikipedia, etc. need to be the ones to slow down piracy. In my opinion, there is no question that piracy needs to be slowed down, but obviously the average American does not know the best way to do it. In fact, Congressmen themselves are sadly not qualified enough to make such decisions. Internet companies argue that proponents of the bill do not know the Internet's infrastructure well enough to know the implications the bill will have. This is likely true but it leaves it up to these companies to act to slow down piracy in a practical manner that won't have unwanted effects because they are the ones who know the technology and practicality of hindering online piracy. Overall, I think it is sad that all these pro- and anti-SOPA videos are being made and are making the average American feel like they now know what should be done. I have know idea how illegal music downloading can be monitored/stopped and I will not know either after watching a two-minute video. Ultimately, the people with the knowledge need to have the integrity to act or otherwise some we will never find the best solution.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The SOPA bill is a very complicated idea. The first time I heard about it was during our class discussions. My mind kept changing back and forth: to support it or not to. I do feel for the music writers and singers that are not getting money that they deserve because copy writing is such a simple task to accomplish. There are so many different way to steal music off of the internet. Theres lime wire, frost wire, you tube and many others. It is so simple as well. If these cites were blocked by SOPA iTunes would have a ton of more money. We would not have a choice but to use iTunes.
    This bill would not only deal with the piracy of music but websites such as; Google, Wikipedia, Yahoo and many others would be harmed. We would no longer have the access to these sites.
    But I would be devastated if the Stop Online Piracy Act was actually passed because I would be so completely lost with out google. When I need to find information quickly, or even a definition I pull up google and within seconds my question is answered.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I true do not believe that SOPA would have been a good idea and I doubt that the intentions of the government where not to protect but to limit. I feel that because of the entire lobbyist in office wanted to pass the bill because it would be for their benefit, and to limit the American citizens in accessing the things that can entertain them. In my opinion SOPA was going to make coins and dimes from this law and the internet watch is generating more money than the entertainment industry. So the reality that the government is really trying to limit the people within society, why does the government not focus at limiting those who endanger the safety of civilians when there are many identity thieves all over the United States? Well because it is not a priority, sorry if I have a sense of biased opinions but I truly do not believe that the government is trying to help, they just do not have the citizen’s interest at hand. So SOPA is completely detriment for the everyday user of the United States. People how are truly being exposed to true threats that are not being addressed by the government.

      Delete
  5. These are all great comments, and a great post. It will be fascinating to see how SOPA or copyright develops in the next bit of time. The internet is a total gamechanger, and it will only be a matter of time until companies have to figure out how to function efficiently in a changing marketplace.

    ReplyDelete